Skip to main content
AR Motorsports
ES
The AR Motorsports showroom at 45 Pine Aire Drive, Bay Shore, NY 11706

SELL YOUR CAR TO AR MOTORSPORTS

Get a Real Offer From a Local
Long Island Dealer

Sell or trade your vehicle without the runaround. Get a real offer from our Bay Shore team. No obligation or new vehicle purchase necessary.

No Obligation

Local Long Island Dealer

We Buy Even If You Don't Buy From Us

Fast Payment

What's Your Car Worth

Tell us about your vehicle to get started

By submitting, you agree AR Motorsports may call, text or email you about your inquiry. Not required to buy. Msg & data rates may apply; reply STOP to opt out. Terms of Service · Privacy Policy

WE BUY CARS ON LONG ISLAND

Sell Your Car to AR Motorsports

Selling a car privately on Long Island means listings, phone calls, and strangers test-driving your vehicle in your driveway, and the national online buyers quote your car sight-unseen from an algorithm. At AR Motorsports, we do it the local way: bring your car to our Bay Shore showroom, or start with a call or text, and get a fair, no-obligation offer from a dealer you can actually walk into.

You don't need to buy a car from us to sell us yours. Sell outright and walk away with payment, or trade in toward your next vehicle from our used car inventory. In New York, you pay sales tax only on the difference after your trade-in credit. We buy cars across Suffolk County and Nassau County, including Bay Shore, Brentwood, Deer Park, Babylon, Islip, Huntington, and the surrounding towns.

Here's the part that matters for your wallet: we specialize in reliable used cars under $10,000, so the older, higher-mileage vehicles the big online buyers turn away or lowball are exactly what we're looking for, and it's why we can often pay more for them.

SIMPLE & FAST

HOW IT WORKS

Three steps from your driveway to money in hand.

1

Tell Us About Your Car

Share a few details about your vehicle.

2

GET YOUR OFFER

Send your details or stop by the showroom for a quick appraisal, and a fair, no-obligation offer.

3

GET PAID

Accept the offer, hand over the keys, and we take care of the paperwork from there.

What to Bring

Vehicle title

Registration

Photo ID

All keys & remotes

Loan payoff info, if financed

Service records, if you have them

Missing something? Call us, we'll walk you through it.

Why Sell To AR Motorsports?

A better experience than

online car buyers.

AR Motorsports National Online Buyers
Local, in-person dealership ✔ Sometimes
Talk to a real person ✔ Sometimes
No purchase required ✔ ✔
Sell or trade your car ✔ ✔
No shipping your car away ✔ -
Local Long Island team ✔ -

REAL PEOPLE.

REAL OFFERS.

RIGHT HERE

ON LONG ISLAND

Sell It Outright

Done with the car? Sell it to us and walk away with payment. No listings, no meetups with strangers, no waiting weeks for the right buyer.

ESTIMATE PAYMENT
Customer handing over car keys after selling a car at AR Motorsports in Bay Shore, NY

Trade Your Car

Put your car's value toward your next vehicle from our inventory. In New York, you only pay sales tax on the difference after your trade-in credit.

VALUE MY TRADE
Trading in a used car at the AR Motorsports showroom in Bay Shore, NY

SKIP THE PRIVATE-SALE HEADACHE

Why Sellers Choose AR Motorsports

We Buy High-Mileage Cars

High miles don't scare us off. We judge a car by how it was kept, not just the odometer, and make real offers the big buyers won't.

Bring Your Online Offer

Already have a number from a national buyer? Show it to us, we'll take a look and try to beat it.

Local, Rated, Accountable

A 4.8-star Google-rated showroom on Pine Aire Drive in Bay Shore, the same people before, during, and after the sale.

WE BUY CARS

Sell Your Car Without the Runaround

Bring your car to Bay Shore or send us the details online. We buy cars from Long Island drivers every week, and you never have to buy from us to sell to us.

READY TO SELL OR TRADE?

Find Out What Your Car Is Worth Today

Get a real offer from a local Long Island dealership. There is no obligation, and you never need to buy from us.

GET MY OFFER

AR Motorsports

•

Bay Shore, NY

SELLING QUESTIONS, ANSWERED

Will you beat my Carvana or CarMax offer?
Bring us your written online offer and we'll take a serious look. Because we specialize in the older, higher-mileage cars the national buyers often lowball, we can frequently do better, and you'll get our answer in person, not from an algorithm.
Can I sell my car and buy one from you the same day?
Yes, that's one of the best reasons to sell local. Sell us your car, browse our inventory, and drive home in your next vehicle the same visit. If you trade in, New York calculates your sales tax on the difference after your trade-in credit, which can save you real money.
Do I have to buy a car from you to sell mine?
No. We buy cars outright with no strings attached. Whether you're trading in or just done with the vehicle, you'll get the same fair, no-obligation offer.
What if I still owe money on my loan?
That's common and usually no problem. Bring your loan payoff information and we'll walk you through how the payoff works as part of the sale.
How do you decide what my car is worth?
A real appraisal by real people, year, make, model, mileage, condition, and what vehicles like yours are actually selling for on Long Island right now. No sight-unseen algorithm, and no offer that mysteriously drops when you arrive. Wondering why that can differ from the Kelley Blue Book number? See is Kelley Blue Book accurate.
How fast do I get paid?
Once you accept our offer and we complete the paperwork, payment is fast. Call us at (631) 333-1233 and we'll walk you through exactly how it works for your situation.
Do you buy cars with high mileage or mechanical issues?
High mileage? Absolutely, reliable used cars with real miles are our specialty, and it's why we can often pay more for them than buyers who don't want them. Have a mechanical issue? Call or text us the details and we'll tell you honestly whether it's a car we can buy.
How long is my offer good for?
Offers are based on the current market, so they don't last forever, we'll tell you exactly how long yours stands when we make it. No pressure either way.

Ready to see what your car is worth?

Call or text (631) 333-1233, photos of your car speed things up.

TEXT US