LONG ISLAND'S TRUSTED USED CAR DEALER
CLEAN TITLE • NO DEALER FEES • FINANCING AVAILABLE • INDOOR SHOWROOM
SHOP OUR FEATURED VEHICLES
WHY DRIVERS CHOOSE AR MOTORSPORTS
NO DEALER FEES
The price you see is the price you pay, always.
CLEAN TITLES
Every vehicle we sell comes with a clean title.
LOW RATES
Our lenders compete to get you a fair rate.
FINANCING FOR ALL
Good credit, bad credit, or no credit.
FAMILY OWNED
Serving Long Island with honesty and integrity.
EXPERT INSPECTION
Every vehicle is inspected and vetted before listing.
YOUR TRUSTED
BAY SHORE DEALER
Proudly serving Bay Shore and all of Long Island with quality used cars, honest pricing, and exceptional service. Stop by our showroom or contact us today. We're here to help.
(631) 333-1233
45 Pine Aire Dr. Bay Shore, NY 11706
Mon – Sat: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
BAY SHORE, SUFFOLK COUNTY
Serving Drivers Across Long Island
AR Motorsports is a used car dealer in Bay Shore, in the heart of Suffolk County. Drivers come to our indoor showroom from across Suffolk County and Nassau County, and from Queens and Brooklyn, for used cars with no dealer fees and financing for every credit situation.
See all the areas we serve →BROWSE INVENTORY BY TYPE
OVER 284
FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
Verified Reviews
See what our customers have to say about their experience with AR Motorsports.
READ ALL REVIEWS"I really love my car! Anthony helped me finance my car very smoothly! Thanks to him I am able to take my dream car home!! I would definitely recommend AR Motorsports!!"
- Karen Pineda
via Google
"Excellent Service, Asking Price Was The Price I Paid No Hidden Nonsense Like The Rest."
- D from Staten Island NY
via Cars.com
"They are by far the best dealership I have ever been to! The sales men (and women) were so wonderfully knowledgeable and helpful! I would definitely recommend AR Motorsports to everyone I know!!! Thanks everyone"
- Oscar L.
via Yelp
WE'LL BUY YOUR CAR
✓Instant Cash Offer
✓All Makes & Models
✓Payoff Existing Loan
✓Free Pickup
✓No Obligation
USED CAR PAYMENT CALCULATOR See what fits your budget before you visit. No credit pull, no signup.
ESTIMATED MONTHLY PAYMENT
$341 /MO*
No SSN impact to estimate
Rates from multiple lenders
All credits welcome
*Estimated payment excludes taxes, title, fees and optional products.
OUR LENDING
PARTNERS
OUR LENDING
PARTNERS
LONG ISLAND'S LARGEST INDOOR SHOWROOM
No matter the weather outside, you can shop comfortably inside our climate-controlled indoor showroom. As Long Island's largest indoor dealership, you can take your time exploring dozens of vehicles, rain or shine.
Climate Controlled
Indoor Showroom
Expert Inspection
Financing Available
Extended Warranties
WHY BUY FROM AR MOTORSPORTS?
Buying a used vehicle shouldn't be stressful. At AR Motorsports in Bay Shore, we make the process simple with transparent pricing, no hidden dealer fees, stress-free financing, and a carefully selected inventory of quality used cars, trucks, and SUVs. We proudly serve drivers across Long Island by treating every customer fairly.
Every vehicle is inspected before being offered for sale, and our team is committed to helping you find the right vehicle, not the most expensive one. Whether you're shopping for a reliable commuter, a first vehicle, or a full-size family SUV, we're here to make buying your next car a positive, pressure-free experience.
Great cars. Honest people. No surprises. That's the AR Motorsports difference.
WHY WE'RE DIFFERENT
| FEATURE | AR MOTORSPORTS | TYPICAL DEALER |
|---|---|---|
| No Dealer Fees | ✓ | ✕ |
| Indoor Showroom | ✓ | ✕ |
| CARFAX Reports | ✓ | Sometimes |
| Financing Options | ✓ | ✓ |
| Vehicle Inspection | ✓ | Limited |
| Free Oil Change | ✓ | Varies |
| Transparent Pricing | ✓ | ✕ |
| Customer Reviews | ★★★★★ | Varies |
SEE THE LOT
Long Island's Premier Used Car Dealer
Take a look around our Bay Shore lot and indoor showroom. Clean cars, one location, and a team that lets you browse without pressure.
BROWSE INVENTORYPopular Searches
Quick links to our most searched used cars,
trucks, and SUVs in Bay Shore, NY.
Used Cars Under $10,000
View Inventory
Used Sedans for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used SUVs for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used Honda for Sale
View Inventory
AWD & 4x4 Vehicles
View Inventory
Used Trucks for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used Toyota for Sale
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $15,000
View Inventory
Used Jeep for Sale
View Inventory
Used Ford for Sale
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $20,000
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $25,000
View Inventory
READY TO FIND YOUR NEXT CAR?
Browse our inventory, get pre-approved,
or value your trade-in.