Serving Bay Shore, NY Used Cars in Bay Shore
GOOD, BAD OR NO CREDIT • NO DEALER FEES • FAST ONLINE APPLICATION
YOUR LOCAL USED CAR DEALER
Bay Shore Is Home
AR Motorsports is not near Bay Shore. We are in it. Our indoor showroom sits at 45 Pine Aire Drive on the north side of town, just off the Sagtikos Parkway, which means most Bay Shore drivers can reach us in about ten minutes from anywhere between Main Street and the Southern State.
This is our hometown, and it shows in the cars we stock. Reliable commuters for the drive to the Bay Shore LIRR station, family SUVs for weekends at the marina or the Fire Island ferries, and dependable first cars for new drivers. When your neighbors are your customers, you cannot afford to sell them a bad car.
Browse our used car inventory online before you visit, get pre-approved for financing in minutes, or bring us a car to sell or trade. Everything happens in one visit, in one building, rain or shine.
Your Neighborhood Used Car Dealer
Fresh Arrivals Near Bay Shore
TRUSTED BY BAY SHORE DRIVERS
REAL CUSTOMERS. REAL EXPERIENCES.
Rodrigo is great sales person i buy 3 cars from them good dealer no hiding fees
Jose Chicas, Bay Shore
via Cars.com
Verified Review
CONVENIENTLY LOCATED
In the Heart of Bay Shore
Minutes from local landmarks, major roadways, and transportation.
~10 min
Bay Shore LIRR Station
~15 min
Fire Island Ferries
~12 min
Main Street Shops
~13 min
South Shore Hospital
ALSO SERVING DRIVERS IN
DRIVERS ACROSS SUFFOLK COUNTY
Proudly helping drivers throughout Long Island find high-quality used cars.
Brentwood
Right next door. Our showroom sits near the Brentwood line, just minutes from anywhere in town.
Used Cars Near Brentwood →
Huntington
A straight run down the Sagtikos from the North Shore, with quality used cars worth the trip.
Used Cars Near Huntington →
Deer Park
Serving Deer Park drivers and nearby communities across western Suffolk County.
Used Cars Near Deer Park →
Babylon
Minutes up from the South Shore via the Southern State, with no dealer fees when you get here.
Used Cars Near Babylon →
FROM PAPERWORK TO PICKUP
We Make Your Purchase Easy
We Handle the DMV Paperwork
Plates, registration, and title work get done at our desk, not in a DMV line. Whether you are coming from Suffolk County, Nassau County, or beyond, you drive away with the paperwork handled.
Detailed and Ready for Pickup
Every vehicle gets a full cleaning and detail before it leaves the showroom. When you arrive, your car is cleaned up and waiting by the door, not sitting dusty in a back row.
STILL DECIDING?
Come See for Yourself
Nobody on Long Island makes buying a used car easier. Other dealers stack fees on top of the price; ours is the price on the windshield. Other lots leave you walking rows in the rain; our indoor showroom is the nicest place on the Island to shop for a car. We are BBB accredited with an A+ rating, a multiple-time nominee for Best of Long Island, and ready to prove it. Come compare us to anyone.
WHY WE'RE DIFFERENT
| FEATURE | AR MOTORSPORTS | TYPICAL DEALER |
|---|---|---|
| No Dealer Fees | ✓ | ✕ |
| Indoor Showroom | ✓ | ✕ |
| CARFAX Reports | ✓ | Sometimes |
| Financing Options | ✓ | ✓ |
| Vehicle Inspection | ✓ | Limited |
| Free Oil Change | ✓ | Varies |
| Transparent Pricing | ✓ | ✕ |
| Customer Reviews | ★★★★★ | Varies |
Popular Searches
Quick links to our most searched used cars,
trucks, and SUVs in Bay Shore, NY.
Used Cars Under $10,000
View Inventory
Used Sedans for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used SUVs for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used Honda for Sale
View Inventory
AWD & 4x4 Vehicles
View Inventory
Used Trucks for Sale Long Island
View Inventory
Used Toyota for Sale
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $15,000
View Inventory
Used Jeep for Sale
View Inventory
Used Ford for Sale
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $20,000
View Inventory
Used Cars Under $25,000
View Inventory
BAY SHORE QUESTIONS, ANSWERED
Where exactly in Bay Shore are you located?
Do you buy cars from Bay Shore residents?
Can I get financing in Bay Shore with bad credit?
Do I need an appointment to visit the showroom?
Ten minutes away, rain or shine.
Stop by the indoor showroom at 45 Pine Aire Drive, Bay Shore.